The Nikon 18-200 lens is not particularly special.In this instance go for the D200 and take a look at the Tamron 18-250mm lens.It is better than both the other lenses.PJT..
Wombat 52 wrote:.
The Nikon 18-200 lens is not particularly special.In this instance gofor the D200 and take a look at the Tamron 18-250mm lens.It is betterthan both the other lenses..
The Nikon is special in the sense that it is stabilized. The Tamron is certainly a better option than the Sigma, but I don't know how it stacks up against the Nikon optically. No superzoom can truthfully claim superior IQ though..
Looking at it from what I shoot, for that budget I'd pick up a used K10d and the Tamron (which is sensor stabilized in that mount). Cost about a grand for the pair..
Between the two options you presented, I'd don't know what I'd do. Stabilization is very useful on lenses this slow, but there are better optical options out there. The 18-200 VR would be a bit of a monster on the little D40 as well. I'd probably be looking at a D80 with an 18-70..
Through the window in the wallCome streaming in on sunlight wingsA million bright ambassadors of morning..
If you could swing it, go with the Sigma 17-70 instead of the tourist zoom. ??.
Rather than the Sigma lens you noted and the Nikon 18-200mm VR, consider the Sigma 18-200mm DC OS. It's got image stabilization like the Nikon and performs very well, IMO. It is not simply the Sigma lens you linked with image stabilization added, it's a new design with different optics.My humble photo gallery: http://ntotrr.smugmug.com.
Image control:Zoom outZoom 100%Zoom inExpand AllOpen in new window..
I'd stick with the choice you made of the D40 and the 18-200 vr. Both will serve you for a long time and give excellent results right out of the box.Cheers, Craig..
Isn't the D40 manual focus only with that lens?Richard..
Isn't the D40 manual focus only with that lens?Richard.
No, the D40 autofocuses with all AF-S lenses, including Nikon's 18-200...
Thanks for the infos..
I'll get the D40/Nikon 18-200mm combination..
There's a great article on this question. Verdict: go for the lens.